7 Comments
User's avatar
nmk's avatar

If there will be a distinction between the bad ideologues and the innocent survivors, of course I will self identify as a survivor too. As a working class person, avoiding unemployment is a basic necessity. And maybe I can even save money for FFS.

But I don’t think such distinction exists IRL.

Aurem's avatar

@wesyang tweeted this recently:

“The trans activist movement created an identity category that anyone could identify into by saying a few words and be given leverage over others that would erase boundaries others would keep them against them.

They thus incentivized troubled, disaffected, and mentally ill youth to identify into the category, which in turn became the sole locus of concern for a cast of affirming clinicians, psychiatrists, and teachers. This would leave the myriad mental health co-morbidities that in nearly all cases accompanied or gave rise to trans ideation unaddressed while children were cheered along as they pursued a descent into unreality that the political and administrative apparatus of this country promised to make true by exerting coercive state power people over the whole country to force them to comply with falsehoods.

This structure of incentives means that over time virtually every disturbed young person from whom the ranks of the violent are drawn will be trans identified -- they will be drawn into a program of self-mortification of their bodies by the false promises of the movement and they will be further disaffected when those promises prove to be false over the medium term as the politico-therapeutic apparatus that promises to remake the world for their convenience proves incapable of delivering on that promise.

These problems are all the necessary and unavoidable entailments of a quixotic and totalitarian political project made up of equal parts scientific and medical fraud, moral and intellectual sophistry, political and legal mendacity, and they cannot be wished away. There has already been a trans Manson Family (the Zizians), a movement desperately eager to generate a trans Emmett Till has already generated a two trans Eric Klebolds. There is worse already baked in. The fault of all of it will be solely on the trans activist movement that declared itself the civil rights movement of the 21s century and no one else.”

https://x.com/wesyang/status/1964003323268223012?s=46&t=Sf5JccIXh3v8zOZpva3P-g

Aurem's avatar

Where can I see pictures of the kittens?

Eric Ireland's avatar

You're right that the murderer was clearly insane in many ways. Genderism is just one more thing that troubled children may identify with. Not the source of the madness.

I keep thinking about Hadley Freeman's article where she said "I’m happy for American female athletes, but needing Trump to sweep out gender ideology is like having to bulldoze your house to get rid of dry rot." I think the Democrats will return to biological reality if enough people just keep calmly dragging them back in the right direction. It might take a long time though. Going all in with Trump, Matt Walsh, Chris Rufo, etc, is not the way.

James Linehan's avatar

He sounded like he was suffering from some form of schizophrenia

Syl's avatar

First off, “gentleman of trans experience” is perfect as an intro. Forget if I’ve mentioned that in the comments on Informed Dissent or not.

I think Cori’s right on this one, Nina. Cori, you’ve been very sharp lately, and I’ve appreciated the more Socratic-style, even if it can be somewhat stressful to listen to for my sensitive weenie brain.

Though, Nina, it *does* feel like “TERF”-ing as such, the earlier iterations of it in particular, before the conservatives moved in, before “Gender Critical is dead! Long live Gender Critical!”, are already being lost to the sands of time. I’d say “memory-holed,” but I don’t think it’s anything that deliberate, really. I’ve tried to explain it, sometimes, to Sailor Strawberry, but it’s almost like… telling fairytales, and I wonder, “Why am I doing this? Is it for him or for me? Am I trying to absolve myself of something?”

He’s worried about similar things as you, Cori, but most worried about same-sex marriage rights potentially being lost, which at first I thought definitely wouldn’t happen, but now I feel more like, well, anything *could* happen. He and his husband are celebrating their ten-year wedding anniversary together with a party this weekend. In our preparations this week, we had an encounter with a high-level sorceress at a local dress shop which should have had a “Danger!” icon outside the door. The owner of the shop was too powerful. We should never have gone there, but it is a beautiful dress. The alterations she threw in to make the sale should be done today.

+1 to Andrea James as a guest, so curious what all this looks like from his perspective.

ETA: Yeah, we got scammed by that dress witch. 😵‍💫

EvieU's avatar

Re: TRAs and Palestine activism… the common thread is hatred for Western Civilization. They believe the ends justify the means for their cultural revolution. On the extreme side of this activism, you have groups like Zizians and Unicorn Ranch. Go even further into the darkness and you find the 764 cult, which is chaos and nihilism, destroy the whole world kind of craziness. Westman’s trans identification was merely an early sign of his psychological instability, he used it as a coping mechanism, he thought it was the answer. Same with other trans identified shooters. The trans identification does not make someone kill someone else, just as the trans identification does not make someone commit suicide.