30 Comments
User's avatar
Linda Jean's avatar

I’m with you, Nina. As someone who is working while disabled, there are times I feel I could work more, but I can only manage to work part time and can’t afford to lose my traditional Medicare with medications that are $18,000 a pop in the free market (negotiated at a super lower rate through CMS). If private health insurance was better for disabled people we wouldn’t need to make these complicated choices in order to continue surviving.

anonyma's avatar

Yeah, Cori's understanding of the benefit cliff is severely lacking here.

Ann's avatar

I perceive you both to be highly ethical people living life and “fighting the good fight” the best that you can. Thank you for your discussion and contributions.

Andrea's avatar

Also, I’m amazed of how silent you are about the richest percent of the population. The ones that get to evade to contribute and can by whatever they want. You’ve just had one at the top of your country and yet you don’t touch the subject. Can I please ask Cory, who do you think will by air and water if it is privatised? What’s their incentive of caring about water or air quality if they get paid for it as opposed to now? Legal consequences? They’ll just pay their way off. They will only get richer by not charing it with nature. Also, Cory needs to learn some ecological principles. We will not survive without bees and such. We will not survive without fungi because of how important they are to nutrients, there actually is an ongoing collapse of nutrients because of industrial cultivation methods. We will not survive without microbiotica, there is an ongoing collapse of health because of the consequences of what we eat to our guts and the soil because of how we cultivate it. So Nina, I believe, wants balance. And that is actually the one realistic way to survive, the growth model is just getting us sicker and weaker. It might be one important reason as to why people don’t want to keep procreating, getting sicker. It is a destructive model. For humans too.

Andrea Exercise's avatar

The American Taxpayer Appreciation episode was great, despite me being a Canadian taxpayer in a Canadian healthcare system. I love your banter and insightful conversation!

KPL's avatar

This is great! Around here there is a “doughnut” - if you make more than 40K you lose so many benefits (Medicaid, SNAP, housing vouchers, childcare vouchers & other benefits-free or reduced bus fare, free museum admission, reduced taxes) that you need to make more than 90-ish K to make up for that! I’m with Cori-it’s no way to set up a welfare system.

Syl's avatar

Helen Pluckrose might be a good guest, re: the British TV license thing. I know she’s written about it. And you could talk about “Cynical Theories” and liberalism, besides!

Andrea's avatar

Thing is, if nobody procreates there will be no one to give Cory his pension. We aren’t saving for ourselves right now but paying the pension of the elderly. So having those maternity-/paternity leave reductions is an investment rather than unnecessary reduction of your salary.

Kim Stevens's avatar

It is unfortunate that Medicaid exists, because all human life has negative value. We are a plague species: 96% of mammalian biomass consists of humans and their livestock and pets. Governmental policies should not be contributing to our continuation.

Andrea's avatar

Also, I think the “shackle program” is worthy of discussing. How the sitting administration dehumanise people from the Spanish Americas. This is what also was chosen when voting it in. They just used the TRA extremism problem as a Trojan horse for xenophobia.

KPL's avatar

Nina, I’m way more empathetic to your situation than I am to what is happening in our state-just found out our state is in huge trouble budget-wise, but for the last 10-ish years we provide health insurance to the undocumented! Yes! Your tax dollars are going to people who can’t legally work (and if they are working they are working *under the table*-making money but not reporting it as income & subsequently underpaying taxes).

anonyma's avatar

I'm afraid your information base needs an update here. Undocumented people are net tax contributors, because they are not eligible for the vast majority of benefit programs. State-funded Medicaid programs in certain circumstances are an exception. Not having work authorization obviously does not mean not working or paying taxes. People without work authorization do not work only under the table; they pay millions of dollars into the American tax base every year, getting very little out. This is why the IRS's recent choice to feed data to ICE is so counterproductive. The choice to fund Medicaid at a state level (and I'd encourage you to review what these programs actually entail: in most states they are extremely limited) is usually a cost saving measure to prevent the higher-cost use of emergency rooms in non-emergent situations by uninsured people, because emergency rooms are legally mandated to provide certain levels of care. You haven't uncovered some crazy liberal secret; people have been studying the economics of this specific issue in depth for decades.

KPL's avatar

Hi! Yes! This used to be true 30-ish years ago! Now in my city & state as soon as you arrive you receive a plethora of services.

KPL's avatar

You can stay in a shelter or hotel for 3 months with option to extend up to 9-12 months. All meals paid for. You receive health benefits immediately. Your children are enrolled in public school immediately receiving special Ed & bilingual education & school breakfast & lunch. You receive healthcare. You also are eligible for a housing voucher for 6 months. So we have created backwards incentives & honestly the research has not caught up.

KPL's avatar

I should add no documentation or work or income requirements is required for any of these services!

anonyma's avatar

You're going to need to be much more specific about who, exactly, and what, exactly, you're talking about here.

KPL's avatar

I should add this is basically Medicaid just for the undocumented. So even less paperwork & documentation needed & less verification than regular Medicaid! This is *unsustainable*.